Book review – In an Absent Dream by Seanan McGuire

Caidyn's review (1)

Buddy read with Sam!


I received an ARC from Tor in exchange for an honest review! This will be published January 8th.

I didn’t love this book.

I had high hopes that this would continue my streak of 4-starring this series, but this kind of ended it. Of course, I’m going to have to round up on Goodreads, but it still is a very solid 3.5 for me.

This story focuses on Lundy. She was a teacher in the first book of the series, but I can’t really say more about her because there are spoilers for later in Every Heart a Doorway. And, this series kind of follows a pattern. One book with a huge adventure, one book of character study, huge adventure, character study. In an Absent Dream falls into a character study part.

I’m not saying that’s a bad thing. I love a good character study, but I think that McGuire really didn’t capitalize on the world. I understand that this is focused on the choices that Lundy made to get her to where we meet her, decades after all of this occurs, as a teacher. However, every driving force felt as if it was left out.

This book follows its own pattern. There were a few chapters of Lundy in our world, then a few where she goes through her doorway, then back in our world, and then the doorway. This back and forth isn’t bad, however there are driving forces that brings her back to our world that just aren’t written. It’s extremely frustrating since everything I wanted to know wasn’t on the page. Hell, there’s even a character who dies and is constantly mentioned throughout the story, but we never even met her and don’t know her personality or anything.

If you want to know and really cared about Lundy from the first book, then I think that you would enjoy seeing the constant wavering of what she wants in her life. The door to her world asks her to be sure, however she is never quite sure what she wants. Until the choice is made for her.

Obviously, this book isn’t a bad one, but it’s frustrating when all the factors that drive Lundy to her decisions aren’t on the page and so I have no real idea what went on. It’s just happened and that’s it and now here she is going back to our world with stories being mentioned but never explored.

And so, alas, this is my least favorite of the series and I had really hoped I would continue rating them higher.

Talk to me!
Have you read this? What did you think?
What’s a book series that had a book that made your rating for the series plummet?

7 thoughts on “Book review – In an Absent Dream by Seanan McGuire

  1. sorry this one was a bit of a letdown for you 😦 my ratings have definitely plummeted for a lot of series – The Winner’s Trilogy is definitely one!

    Liked by 1 person

    • I haven’t read that series, but I have heard iffy things about it. And, I was bummed on this one, too! Sam loved it and I’ve seen other glowing reviews of it, but it wasn’t for me. So, alas. I’m hopeful the next book will be great.


  2. Pingback: In an Absent Dream: ARC Review – Tinted Prose Reviews

  3. Pingback: October wrap-up – BW Reviews

  4. Pingback: In an Absent Dream: ARC Review | Tinted Prose Reviews

  5. Pingback: Top Ten Tuesday – Most Anticipated Releases for the First Half of 2019 – BW Reviews

  6. Pingback: January Book Haul – BW Reviews

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s